Diversity in learning materials
In a class on pedagogy, the teacher uses Powerpoint slides to depict different examples of how students learn and interact in the classroom. The pictures are cartoons, but the one for the student who is distracted in class and unengaging is represented as a person of colour while all the others are not.
In a criminal law course, the class discusses a hypothetical case of theft where one person, with an Arabic sounding name steals something from a person with a Dutch sounding name. A student in the class with an Arabic background feels very uncomfortable doing the assignment and discussing it in class.
Do you see yourself represented in the learning materials that you use in class? Are there people of your class, sex, or religion that you can identify with in the case studies? For many students from minority groups, they are used to never seeing themselves represented in any of the examples given or in the authors assigned to read in class. Dei, G. (2016). Decolonizing the university: The challenges and possibilities of inclusive education. Socialist Studies/Études Socialistes, 11(1), 23-23. . This lack of diversity in university learning materials is problematic for several reasons. First, only/mainly assigning literature written by male Western authors who researched Western subjects, can give the impression that such research is superior and marginalizes the perspectives and knowledge of other authors. Second, students who do not see themselves represented in the pictures and examples used in class can come to feel inferior. A meta-analysis by Bowman (2001) has shown that when the curriculum is made more diverse there is an increase in (civic) engagement by university students Bowman, N. A. (2011). Promoting participation in a diverse democracy: A meta-analysis of college diversity experiences and civic engagement. Review of Educational Research 81 (1), 29-68. doi: https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654310383047 . In the future, UU students are likely to work in a diverse society that requires the knowledge and skills to do so. For instance, intercultural competences are an indispensable skill for, ie, lawyers, nurses, and politicians Hamilton, J. (2009). Intercultural competence in medical education – essential to acquire, difficult to assess. Medical Teacher, 31:9, 862-865, DOI: 10.1080/01421590802530906 . In this section, we provide tools to help you improve the diversity and inclusivity of the literature, examples, and visuals within a university course.
Tools
This section presents three tools for improving diversity in learning materials. The first tool helps teachers to scan their course’s assigned literature. The second and third tools help teachers to assess if different aspects of diversity are (well) presented in their learning material, and to identify any stereotypical cases/examples and provide examples for improvement. These tools are an adaptation of the ‘Literature Scan’ developed by Kathrine van den Bogert, Elke Linders and Nicole Sanches from the department of Cultural Anthropology, Utrecht University. The original tool can be found here.
The following steps can assist in making course learning materials more inclusive and diverse.
- What do I have now?
- What is missing and is that a problem?
- Finding appropriate replacements
- Make it explicit
The first step relates to getting an overview of the status quo of your learning material regarding diversity and inclusion. For reading material, this relates to the disciplinary perspective, content of the literature, background of the author, and empirical data on which the findings are based. For visuals and examples/cases, this relates to whether different aspects of diversity are represented and, if so, whether this is done in a stereotypical manner or not. The second step helps teachers to decide whether to make changes to the learning material and the third step helps in finding appropriate replacements. The fourth step assists teachers when communicating to students the choices made in selecting the learning material and any potential gaps in perspectives.
Diversity in Literature
This section provides information and tools to improve both the diversity of authors assigned as reading material as well as the content of the literature. We do this through the following steps:
- What do I have now?
- What is missing and is that a problem?
- Finding appropriate literature
- Making it explicit
1. What do I have now?
Before you can start improving the diversity of the literature assigned in your course, you need to understand the status quo. Complete the scheme below to get an overview, while noting that some information may be difficult to find. Click here to download the scheme.
Literature
Name of article/book chapter | (Sub)disciplinary perspective | Are any differences in aspects of diversity (e.g. sex/gender, sexual orientation, ethnicity/nationality, disability (mental or physical), religious background, socioeconomic status or age) discussed. If so, which? | Background of author in terms of aspects of diversity (if known) | For literature based on empirical observations of humans, background of participants in the study |
2. What is missing and is that a problem?
Coomer, M. N., Skelton, S. M., Kyser, T. S., Warren, C., & Thorius, K. A. K. (2017). Assessing bias In standards and curricular materials. Equity Tool. Indianapolis, IN: Great Lakes Equity Center.Having completed the scheme above, you should now have an overview of the literature assigned in your course and can start considering what might need to change. This can happen in three steps: 1) identify what is missing in terms of diversity; 2) consider whether this is something that fits within your course; and 3) what literature might best be replaced/added. To assist in this process, consider the questions below:
- Is there an intersection between the diversity aspects (e.g., not only women but also women of color)?
- Are the diversity aspects within literature treated as issues or social problems instead of enrichment?
- Are the study participants/authors mostly from the West or the Netherlands itself?
- Which voices have to date been marginalised or silenced on the topic of your course?
- Are the diversity aspects that are missing in the course content, aspects that are important for students to learn about in this field?
- Is an international or non-Western perspective relevant to your course or is the focus exclusively on the Dutch context?
- What diversity aspects do other courses within the program address?
- Do the learning materials that you want to add/replace require a change in the learning objectives (see this section on how to do this)?
3. Finding appropriate literature
If you already have a clear idea on what is missing from your literature and what you are looking for, this section provides several entry points, suggestions, and additional information related to finding that literature. To avoid ‘tunnel vision’, it can be helpful to take a few ‘breaks’ in the process of searching and selecting. In such a break you can go (back) to the literature scheme, to take a moment to see what you already have and what still might be missing. Coomer, M. N., Skelton, S. M., Kyser, T. S., Warren, C., & Thorius, K. A. K. (2017). Assessing bias In standards and curricular materials. Equity Tool. Indianapolis, IN: Great Lakes Equity Center.
General tips and recommendations
- Try searching in a different library, such as https://feministsearchtool.nl/ which focuses on literature by a diverse range of authors.
- Do a literature search on the topic of your course, where you focus on diversity issues within that are relevant for that topic or where you focus on how a certain topic affects marginalized groups. For example, in a course on educational psychology, you can do a literature search to examine whether learning principles have also been investigated for first-generation students.
- Invite guest lecturers from diverse backgrounds or whose who have done research into diversity aspects within your topic. Ask these guest lecturers to bring in literature that complements the literature in your course but brings in a different perspective.
4. Make it explicit
Now that you have gone through the first three steps, you may want to communicate your findings to your colleagues and/or students. Coomer, M. N., Skelton, S. M., Kyser, T. S., Warren, C., & Thorius, K. A. K. (2017). Assessing bias In standards and curricular materials. Equity Tool. Indianapolis, IN: Great Lakes Equity Center.
General tips and recommendations
- Use the literature scheme as a starting point for a discussion with your colleagues regarding which materials, authors or perspectives they believe are missing or could be added.
- Write down the names of authors fully in the reading list, so that it might be easier to identify which is female or from a particular cultural background.
- Given the limitations, it is unlikely that all perspectives can be covered in one course. However, it can be helpful to explain the choices made as a lecturer and for students to know that teachers are interested in making the literature as inclusive as possible.
- Consider inviting your students to suggest authors or materials that could be included in the syllabus.
Diversity in examples/cases and visuals
- What do I have now?
- What is missing and is that a problem?
- Avoiding stereotypical visuals or examples/cases and finding alternatives (with example)
- Make it explicit
- What do I have now?
In this step, teachers should examine the current status of visuals and examples/cases used in their course. There are two main questions to consider. First: Are people from diverse backgrounds (well) represented in the course material? For example, people from a range of genders (i.e., male, female, non-binary) are included in examples, cases and/or visuals. Or intersections between diversity aspects (e.g., a person who is both female and a Muslim) are included in examples, cases and/or visuals. Second: if such people are portrayed, is this done in a non-stereotypical way? For example, when discussing professions, make sure that pictures do not always portray men in business professions and women in care professions. Also, examine whether it is necessary to include information about ethnicity or nationality in your examples, especially if the example may portray a certain group in a negative way (e.g., with respect to criminal behavior). Coomer, M. N., Skelton, S. M., Kyser, T. S., Warren, C., & Thorius, K. A. K. (2017). Assessing bias In standards and curricular materials. Equity Tool. Indianapolis, IN: Great Lakes Equity Center.
2. What is missing and is this a problem?
Depending on the number of examples/cases and visuals used within the course, it might be difficult to cover all aspects of diversity. Therefore, choices might need to be made which to include although having examples with people that are diverse in multiple aspects can help. Moreover, you can take the following two things into consideration:
- Which diversity aspects are most related to the topic of the course?
- Which people are students most likely to come across in their future work?
- Which people are mostly underrepresented in the visuals and examples/cases?
3. Avoiding stereotypes in examples and visuals
When making the cases/examples and visuals within the course more diverse, it is important to be aware of stereotyping. That is, when you include people with a diverse background in your examples/cases or visuals, you may want to bear in mind that they are not displayed in a stereotypical manner.
4. Make it explicit
Now that you have identified and adapted the visuals and cases/examples in your learning materials, you may want to communicate what you have done to your colleagues and/or students.
General tips and recommendations
- Use these examples as input for a discussion with your colleagues to discuss if they believe any minority groups are missing in cases/examples and visuals and if they believe there to be any stereotypes in the learning material
- It is likely that not all aspects of diversity are covered, but it may be helpful for students to know that teachers are devoted to making cases/examples and visuals as inclusive and diverse as possible. So be open about your selection and its gaps to your students and invite them to make suggestions for improvement!
Additional Resources
https://youtu.be/HttFlDRuLek (Video about uncovering stereotypes in classroom materials)